Home / Blog / AED Brands: Philips Defibrillator vs. Physio-Control LIFEPAK CR Plus

AED Brands: Philips Defibrillator vs. Physio-Control LIFEPAK CR Plus

Philips vs. Physio Control

 

Philips vs. Physio Control

AED Brands: Philips Defibrillator vs. Physio-Control LIFEPAK CR Plus

 

Whether you need an AED for the office, school, home, or gym, you want to know that the AED works 100%. That is why it is so important to look into the features and inclusions of each AED to make sure you select the best. One of the more common AEDs is the Philips Onsite defibrillator – an AED supplied and supported by First Edition First Aid Inc. Another commonly known AED is Physio-Control LIFEPAK CR Plus. Whereas most AEDs have many similarities, these two AEDs are more different than alike, in battery, layout and design, and shock administration. Here we will compare Philips vs. Physio-Control to help you better decide what AED is the best option.

 

Physio-Control LIFEPAK CR Plus

Physio-Control Lifepak CR Plus

Physio-Control LIFEPAK CR Plus Price and Accessories

The Physio-Control LIFEPAK CR Plus is an AED that looks very similar to other models. What makes it different is the layout and design below the cover as well as the fully automated approach. This AED is made for ease of use, requiring less from the responder and instead, having the machine do the work. The Physio-Control AED is priced around $1,695 but may differ depending on the retailer and package.

 

The standard Physio-Control LIFEPAK CR Plus package includes the following (may vary depending on retailer):

  • LIFEPAK CR Plus AED
  • Owner’s manual
  • Training DVD
  • AMBU® Res-Cue Key®
  • First Responder Kit
  • CHARGE-PAK™ charger
  • 2 sets of QUIK-PAK™ electrodes
  • Carry Case
  • 8 Year Warranty

 

Physio-Control LIFEPAK CR Plus Battery and Pads

Physio-Control LIFEPAK CR Plus Battery

The batteries for most AEDs are either individual lithium batteries or a single long-life battery. But unlike other AEDs, the Physio-Control batteries have a charge and require frequent replacements. The charge pack and pads need replacing after every use or every 2 years. The Physio-Control CHARGE-PAKs charge the machine. Once the triangle shaped CHARGE-PAK is inserted, the AED requires 3 days to fill up the internal battery. Why is this worth noting? The AED needs time to “top up” in a timeframe where an emergency could occur.

 

Physio-Control LIFEPAK CR Plus Shock Administration

In some cases, it is beneficial for machines to take control in an emergency. With the Physio-Control fully automated AED, shocks are administered by the machine once assessed; easy for any civilian to administer. However, it is important for the victim not to be touched when a shock is administered. If the victim is touched during the shock sequence, the shock can pass through to that person in contact, causing harm. Unlike the Philips AED that allows you to take time to ensure everyone is away, the Physio-Control AED does not. It will automatically administer the shock shortly after warning everyone to “clear.” In cases where there is a frantic family member, they may be too focused on being close to the individual than listening to the machine’s instructions. Without the extra step of a manual initiation after the scene has been cleared, there could be two people needing emergency attention.

 

Physio-Control LIFEPAK CR Plus Design and Layout

Physio Control LIFEPAK CR Plus Design

The Physio-Control LIFEPAK CR Plus has a unique design that keeps everything stored within the AED lid. It is only when you press the button on the bottom of the AED that the lid will open – automatically turning on the AED.

 

Underneath the lid is also the connector for the defibrillator pads. When you connect the pads to the AED, a small black tab must also be attached to keep the pad package in place. In an emergency, a red handle on the secured pad package is pulled to access the pads themselves. These few quick steps can add up in the stress of an emergency, resulting in time delays.

 

Unlike other AED’s that have screens or lights to indicate steps, the Physio-Control AED seems to be lacking visual cues. When in use, individuals must rely on the voice activated controls for guidance. There are informational stickers located on the inside of the lid, but little is required as the system and process are automated. For a person using an AED for the first time, this could be daunting as little visual information is given.

 

 

Philips Onsite AED

Philips AED

Philips Onsite AED Price and Accessories

The Philips Onsite AED strives to take the confusion out of saving a life. With its easy-to-use approach, labeled buttons and diagrams, and voice-activated instructions, anyone can save a life. The compact case makes it easy to transport (perfect for off-site work) as well as simple to store (convenient for homes, schools, and offices). The Philips Onsite AED is priced at $1,896  and is available for purchase through First Edition First Aid Inc. Although the Philips AED is priced slightly higher than the Physio-Control AED, the price identifies the quality of the machine and the reputation of the brand. You want your AED to work all the time, every time, and the Philips Onsite AED can provide that.

 

The standard Philips Onsite Defibrillator package includes the following:

  • Onsite AED (Includes 1 battery)
  • 2 adult SMART pads II
  • Carrying Case
  • Fast Response Kit
  • DVD
  • 8 Year Warranty (additional 2-year warranty extension available)

 

Philips Onsite AED Battery and Pads

Philips Battery

The battery included in the Philips Onsite AED is easy to replace and long-lasting. The single unit lithium manganese dioxide battery has a warranty of 4 years once installed and a 5-year shelf life. These efficient batteries do not need extra attention over the 4-years, and are reliable any time in that period for emergencies. The 2 adult SMART pads II included in the package have a warranty of 30 months, longer than the Physio-Control pads.

 

Philips Onsite AED Shock Administration

When an emergency occurs and an AED is in use, it is crucial to make sure no one is touching the individual when shocks are administered. A machine cannot see if loved ones are too close or in contact with the individual. Only a human can identify if everyone is clear and whether or not a shock is ready to be given. The Philips Defibrillator allows you to choose when to administer a shock. The AED will notify you if a shock is needed, tell you to stay clear, and then tell you to press the shock button. This extra step gives the responder time to make sure everyone is away from the individual and can administer the shock at their own judgment.

 

Philips Onsite AED Layout and Design

Philips Onsite Design

The Philips Onsite AED is a compact and ready for immediate use. All the buttons are easily accessible on the front of the AED. Unlike the Physio-Control AED, only the power button needs pressing to turn on the AED and begin use. The AED pads are also contained on the front of the AED. Simply pulling off the plastic panel will release the pads. The AED pad connectors are already connected underneath the pads, out of the way of any buttons or lid.

 

The Philips AED is useable by anyone. Even those with no AED experience can maneuver it with the assistance of voice-activated instructions. In addition to the instructions, lit buttons will indicate what step is needed. The simple voice instructions, lit steps, and easy-to-understand images placed on the pads make the Philips Onside AED layout a great choice.

 

 

It is an important decision to select an AED for your home, work site, office, or anywhere else you spend time. That is why it is clear that the Philips Onsite AED is the best option for its ease of use, reduced time, and low maintenance. Although the price of the Physio-Control LIFEPAK CR Plus is lower than the Philips defibrillator, when choosing an AED, price should not be the determining factor. You need an AED that you can rely on and trust to work 100% of the time! Choose the Philips Onsite AED and know that you are truly prepared for any emergency.

 

 

 

 

Sources:

http://www.physio-control.com/faq.aspx?id=2147485827

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D76z_MGRfFk

https://aed4life.ca/lifepak-cr-plus

 

Images:

http://cardiac-solutions.net/file/2016/03/Physio-Control-Lifepak-CR-Plus-AED-min-1-258×300.png

https://www.aedpeople.com/resize/Shared/Images/Product/Medtronic-Physio-Control-LIFEPAK-CR-Plus-AED/Medtronic_Physio_Control_Wall_Auto_Open_L_LIFEPAK_CR_Plus_AED_Defibrillator.jpg?bw=1000&w=1000&bh=1000&h=1000

https://www.batteries4pro.com/4345/load-pak-12v-for-defibrillator-lifepak-cr-plus-physiocontrol.jpg

http://www.shopfirstaid.ca/store/sc_images/philips_onsite_aed_with%20extra%20pads%20case%20and%20responder%20kit.jpg

https://hdsupplysolutions.com/wcsstore/ThdsMroUs/product/fm/large/60/605854_V_L.jpg

https://cdn3.volusion.com/fcyht.cmaff/v/vspfiles/photos/M5066A-3.jpg

 

WordPress Themes